George Zimmerman: The Witness 8 InterviewsBy Jeralyn, Section Crime in the News
Posted on Tue Oct 23, 2012 at 06:54:59 PM EST
The full version of the October 19 hearing in the George Zimmerman case is now available without commentary on You Tube
Of particular interest to me are the issues surrounding Witness 8, aka "Dee Dee", Trayvon Martin's phone friend who reportedly was speaking with Travyon in the minutes leading up to the shooting. The media has referred to her as "Dee Dee", but her true identity is protected by court order (so please don't speculate on it here, that's not the point of this post.)
When Martin family lawyer Benjamin Crump held a press conference in Ft. Lauderdale on March 20, to introduce the nation to the existence of this witness, he played a tape recording of a telephone interview he conducted with her the day before. He said the interview shows George Zimmerman's version of the events leading up to the shooting are not believable. The transcript of his press conference is here. Crump announced he would send the recording to the Justice Department.
Video (part 1)http://www.wftv.com/videos/news/lawyer- ... ase/vGcBx/Video (part 2.) http://www.wftv.com/videos/news/lawyer- ... ase/vGcFM/The state interviewed this witness on April 2, after getting her phone records. The state released recordings of both its April 2 interview and the copy of the Crump interview in discovery. While the recording of the state's interview with witness 8 on April 2 is fairly audible, the Crump interview it provided is mostly unintelligible, which the defense complained about at the hearing on Friday and in a motion.
The defense stated at the hearing that ABC News aired clips from the recording of the Crump-Dee Dee interview, which ABC reporter Matt Gutman said he obtained exclusively. Curiously, the Gutman aired clips are perfectly clear. See here, as
an example.http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/video/neighbo ... s-15959779 Also see the Gutman clips Diwataman has assembled.http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/trayvon ... n-15965498http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/video/trayvon ... e-15968634http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/trayvon ... s-15982638http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/george- ... n-16006988http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/trayvon ... n-16024564http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/video/zimmerm ... d-16027322http://abcnews.go.com/Nightline/video/q ... e-16035381On March 28, Matt Gutman tweeted that he is the only person with a copy of the recording. In another ABC interview, Gutman said:
Martin's father, Tracy Martin, and mother, Sybrina Fulton, listened to the call, along with ABC News, ashen-faced.
It turns out Matt Gutman says he spoke with Witness 8 several times the week of March 19. From his appearance on MSNBC's Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell on March 28 (transcript available on Lexis.com):
Quote:
O`DONNELL: Matt, quickly before you go, you talked to her. What`s your assessment of her credibility?
GUTMAN: I think she`s credible. I don`t think she has anything to hide here. We`ve been talking to her for days now. This is not the first time that I`ve heard her speak. I have no reason to believe that she`s lying.
Obviously, you know, at some point, this may or may not go to court, and she could be subpoenaed. But at the very least I think that it`s obvious since her number is in the phone record, which is how we got to her, that the police should have talked to her, at least interviewed her. But they never have.
O`DONNELL: They still haven`t?
GUTMAN: That`s one of the most surprising things about this case.
O`DONNELL: Matt, the police still haven`t talked to her?
GUTMAN: No. [Ap]parentally prosecutors plan to meet her next Monday, but that`s only because the new set of prosecutors just came in.
Why has the state not bothered to subpoena Gutman's copy of Crump's March 19 interview with Dee Dee, or Gutman's other interviews with her? Does it not want to know if her statements are consistent with what she said in her interview with the state's attorney on April 2?
The Court on Friday ordered Benjamin Crump be made a witness for the purpose of having his deposition taken about his interview with Dee Dee. It also ordered him to tell the defense within 10 days who else was present during his recorded interview with her, and to bring the phone to the deposition if he still has a copy of the recording on his phone,.
But nothing further was discussed at the hearing about the Gutman interviews of Dee Dee. Again, it's not just the recording Gutman has of the March 19 Crump interview, but his own conversations with her after that date. ....
....snip.....
On a secondary note, during the hearing argument on the defense subpoena to obtain Witness 8's twitter records, prosecutor De La Rionda told the court he had disclosed her real name to the Defense, but challenged the defense's conclusion she is a juvenile and she was the author of the tweets O'Mara is seeking. On being a juvenile, BDLR asked several times, "Has that been proven?" Was he referring to whether Witness #8 is a juvenile or whether the person whose tweets O'Mara is seeking is a juvenile? O'Mara seemed to think he was referring to Witness 8.
....more at linkhttp://www.talkleft.com/story/2012/10/23/195459/60